The Movie
I am always amazed at how movies made from books never quite live up to the books they are made from (except for Lord of the Rings). And yes, I realize you can’t have the same depth of character development, and especially in cases where the book is long you have to abridge the plot in order to keep the movie version within a reasonable length.
In this case, though, the two were substantially different. Tom Hanks character, Robert Langdon, wasn’t quite the kindred spirit of Leigh Teabing (Ian McKellan) that he was in the book. In fact, he was in several instances combative with Teabing’s railings against Jesus, the church and the Bible. The movie did follow the plot line of seeking the Holy Grail as the remains of Mary Magdalene, and even more conclusively establishing that Sophie was of the bloodline of Jesus through Mary.
I went, expecting that the movie would be a truer representation of the book in its invectives against the church and the Bible. The claims made about Constantine and the Council of Nicea and the canonicity of the Bible and the divinity of Jesus were all historically inaccurate (as they were in the book), but the movie seemed to soften the tone and made them a part of Teabing’s eccentricity instead of statements of long-accepted historic fact. Of course, the notion that Jesus and Mary were married and conceived a child was offensive as well as erroneous, but the movie’s portrayal of it came across more as a fictitious plotline in a whodunit movie than the book’s arrogant rendering of academic research behind the statements.
Was I offended? Only as offended as I usually am when Hollywood attempts to do theology. Will this movie threaten people’s faith? Only the most gullible, biblically illiterate, conspiracy theorists. Would I recommend it? I’ve spent $4 and watched worse movies, but I would recommend you go ahead and splurge with the buttered popcorn (and get the refill) – that will be the highlight (that and the amazingly tiny car Sophie drives in reverse through the streets of Paris!)


